
I left the Army in 2010 and retrained in plumbing, and in 2011 I joined a small renewables company installing ground source and air source heat pumps. I spent six years there. It was a small team, so I learned every part of the job, from big Grand Designs style houses to a few commercial installs. I set up Eco Pro Renewables in 2016, and since moving to Devon I have also worked as a freelance MCS assessor for NAPIT, which means I go out to other installation companies and assess their work.
COMPARE PRICES FROM LOCAL INSTALLERS
Compare prices from local companies fast & free
Enter your postcode to compare quotes from leading professionals. We promise to keep your information Safe & Secure. Privacy Policy
That work shapes how I read a quote, and a house in Somerset is a good example of why.
The owner had an ageing oil boiler that was getting unreliable and expensive to run. Before they rang us, three other companies had been round. One recommended a 16kW heat pump. Another told them the property wasn't suitable for a heat pump at all. With advice that far apart, the homeowner had lost confidence and didn't know who to trust, and I can't blame them.
We started with a free home visit and then carried out a full room-by-room heat loss survey. Our calculations showed the house was suitable for a heat pump, though not the 16kW unit one company had proposed. We sized the heat pump to the heat loss we measured and upgraded only the radiators that needed replacing. The install took five working days.
The size matters in both directions. If a heat pump's output is too small, it won't heat the house properly. If it's too large, it will cost too much to run. The job of the design is to get that balance right, so that on the coldest day of the year the heat pump can still heat the home efficiently. In my experience that is where a lot of people go wrong with heat pumps: they don't design the installation correctly.
What I check when I assess another installer's job
As an MCS assessor, I visit installations carried out by other companies and check them against the MCS standards. I look at everything from system sizing and pipework to commissioning, the documentation, the office quality management system and overall compliance. It means I see the good and the bad across the industry, and I know what a properly designed and installed heat pump should look like.
It's worth knowing these checks exist. If your installer applies for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant on your behalf, gov.uk explains that Ofgem will contact you to confirm the installer is acting for you, and Ofgem or MCS may also check the installation.
For sizing, I go back to the heat loss survey. Done properly, a survey takes me just over half a day. I walk through the property with the homeowner and explain the radiator requirements as I go. From the results I size the heat pump, work out which radiators stay and which need upsizing, and set the temperature the system will run at.
Why the radiator count tells you something
Your boiler is probably pumping water round your radiators at 70 to 80°C. With a heat pump we design for a flow temperature of around 45 to 50°C. It is much more efficient to run at that lower temperature for longer, and it gives a more comfortable, consistent heat. Because the water going through the radiators is cooler, some of them may need upsizing slightly to meet the heat loss of each room. A room-by-room survey tells you exactly which ones.
A 1930s six-bedroom house we did in Exmouth is a good example. It had 34 windows, and the owners weren't sure a heat pump could heat a house like that. The heat loss calculations showed that seven radiators needed upgrading at a design flow temperature of 47°C. We kept the rest, which kept unnecessary costs down, and every room stays warm through the winter.
A detached house in Newton Abbot went the other way. It was poorly insulated and heated by a 20-year-old Aga-style back boiler. After the survey it was clear that swapping the heat source alone wouldn't work. Someone had designed the old system around a high-temperature boiler, with undersized pipework through much of the house restricting the flow. We replaced the distribution pipework with pipe sized for the flow rates a low-temperature system needs and fitted fourteen new radiators, including in rooms that previously had none. Seven radiators in one house and fourteen plus new pipework in another both came from the same method.
On insulation: it's a common misconception that your house has to be super insulated or a new build. Any heating system, gas, oil or heat pump, will be more efficient with insulation. The heat loss of your property is what it is, and we design the heat pump to meet that heat loss.
Questions to ask before you sign
If you're holding two or three quotes that disagree, these are the questions I'd want answered, based on what I check on other people's jobs and what goes into my own.
- Who will carry out the room-by-room heat loss survey, and will I get the results for each room?
- What size of heat pump are you proposing, and how did the heat loss figures get you to that size?
- Which radiators need changing, and what flow temperature have you sized them for?Have you done the sound calculation? It's part of the MCS requirements, and it checks that neighbours won't be affected by noise.
- What hot water cylinder are you fitting? I install a new heat pump specific cylinder with every system, because the larger coil transfers the heat much more efficiently.
- Are you MCS certified, and will you apply for the grant and take it off the quote? On gov.uk the grant, if you are eligible, is currently £7,500 towards an air source heat pump, with an extra £1,500 until March 2027 if your home is heated by oil or LPG and has no mains gas connection. The installer applies on your behalf and the grant should show on your quotation and invoice.
- Who do I ring if something needs attention after handover?
Ask that last one even if it feels awkward. A lot of homeowners are cautious before they pick up the phone because of the horror stories about poor installations, and they want to know someone will still be there later. My customers deal with me from the first visit through to commissioning and aftercare, and if something needs attention, we don't disappear.
About the author
James Stalker runs Eco Pro Renewables in Exmouth, Devon, and works as a freelance NAPIT MCS assessor, auditing other installers' heat pump jobs. He has worked on heat pumps since 2011, and his team takes Devon homes off oil and LPG onto heat pumps.
Find a local installer
Welcome to the biggest directory of UK renewable energy companies